Cayuga Lake's Protected Lake Monster: An Investigation into Old Greeny

0:00-44:43

In 1804, a newspaper claimed two fishermen shot and killed a 100-foot serpent in Cayuga Lake. Over 200 years later, the city of Ithaca has an official resolution protecting it. In this episode, I team up with Kenny Biddle, Chief Investigator at the Center for Inquiry, to dig through the old newspaper trail, measure the monster, and talk to the people keeping the legend alive. Along the way, we talk to Sylvie, creator of the Old Greeny Fringe Fest; Pat Sewell, the alder behind the resolution; and Ben Sandburg, executive director of the History Center in Tompkins County. Plus, there’s a pattern in the sighting dates that says Old Greeny is “due to return,” and I explain why that math should make you suspicious. I’m Ally, an environmental scientist who manages lakes for a living, and this is AquaDiary: lake science, legends, and mysteries. GUESTS Kenny Biddle, Center for Inquiry: https://skepticalinquirer.org/category/a-closer-look/ Sylvie, Old Greeny Fringe Fest: https://oldgreenyfringefest.com/ Pat Sewell, Ithaca Common Council, Third Ward Ben Sandburg, Tompkins County History Center: https://www.thehistorycenter.net/ SUPPORT THE LAKE MONSTERS“Save Our Lake Monsters” shirts are available at aquadiary.org

Publisher

AquaDiary: Water Mysteries, Science & News

Link

podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/aquadiarypodcast/episodes/Cayuga-Lakes-Protected-Lake-Monster-An-Investigation-into-Old-Greeny-e3qj599

Published

October 16, 2026

Duration

45 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Issues · Science

Source

RSS feed

Host

Ally Berry

AW

AquaDiary: Water Mysteries, Science & News

@aquadiarywatermysteriesscien

#cayugalakesprotected #investigation #oldgreeny #naturalsciences

The Nile