The Faceless Woman of Silver Lake: A True Maine Haunting

0:00-38:10

CW: Descriptions of violence Is Sarah Ware still searching for justice? Or is something older wearing her shape? In 1898, Bucksport, Maine was shaken by the brutal and still‑unsolved murder of Sarah Ware. More than a century later, witnesses continue to report chilling encounters around — and beneath — the waters of Silver Lake. In this episode, we explore the life and death of Sarah MacDonald Ware, the investigation that failed to bring her killer to justice, and the decades of ghostly sightings that followed. From Almira Miles’ early claims of spectral knocks to modern encounters on the lake’s hiking trails, Sarah’s story refuses to fade. Featuring a special voiceover from Maine author and researcher Nomar Slevik, this episode seeks to uncover what might still linger in the dark waters of Silver Lake. If you enjoy the show please leave a rating on your audio platform of choice as it helps the show get in the ears of more listeners. New episodes of the Fogcast go up every Monday. Become a Lantern Holder on Patreon to gain access to ad free episodes a day early, as well as bonus digital content and the Lantern Logbook. Visit acadiaafterdark.com for more horror from the foggy coast of Maine. Keep those lanterns lit and stay safe out there hikers... Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Publisher

Acadia After Dark

Link

shows.acast.com/acadia-after-dark/episodes/6a29d17f7fe177e75b5e13fc

Published

June 12, 2026

Duration

38 min

Format

Podcast

Category

News · Daily News

Source

RSS feed

Host

Christian Leathers

AA

Acadia After Dark

@acadiaafterdark

#facelesswoman #silverlake #mainehaunting

The Nile