The Last Ride | 53 Years Later, DNA Reveals Who Murdered Two Teenage Sisters

Episode 451

0:00-38:51

On the morning of May 3rd, 1973, a man out walking his dog in Key Largo, Florida, stepped into a stretch of woods about a hundred yards off U.S. 1. Near mile marker 99.5, under a layer of sticks, leaves and dirt, he found two teenage girls. They were sisters. Maggie Jenkins was 18. Mary Jenkins was 16. They had come down from New Jersey for a spring trip to Key West, and less than 24 hours earlier, someone had seen them standing on the side of the road with their luggage, trying to hitch a ride home. For 53 years, nobody could say who...

Publisher

Crime Weekly

Link

www.crimeweeklypodcast.com

Published

October 28, 2026

Duration

39 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Entertainment · True Crime & Justice

Source

RSS feed

Host

Stephanie Harlowe and Derrick Levasseur

CW

Crime Weekly

@crimeweekly

#yearslater #dnareveals #teenagesisters

The Nile