The Sunday Interview: Matthew Taylor on Risking Everything to Confront Christian Supremacy

0:00-52:25

On this Sunday Interview, Annika Brockschmidt talks with scholar of religion and theologian Matthew Taylor about his new book, Defying Tyrants, Following Jesus: In a World of Christian Antichrists. Writing as a Christian to other Christians, Taylor argues that the propaganda fueling MAGA and the authoritarian turn in American politics is theological, and that the response must be too. He explains why he sees Christian supremacy, the belief that Christians are better than others and entitled to power, as an older and deeper problem than Christian nationalism, tracing it through Constantine, Christendom, the Crusades, and colonialism. Taylor then offers a close reading of 1 and 2 John, where "antichrist" appears mostly in the plural and refers to people who broke away from the community and abused others in Christ's name, which leads him to argue that Christian antichrists are Christians who abuse power under Jesus's banner. They also discuss how to reckon with Christian awfulness without retreating to the "no true Scotsman" defense, what kind of king Jesus actually is, and the personal cost of the book: Taylor lost his job at an interfaith institute because of it. He explains why he refused to withdraw it, and what ordinary Christians can do to resist Christian supremacy in their everyday lives. If you enjoy our work, please subscribe.

Publisher

Straight White American Jesus

Published

October 18, 2026

Duration

52 min

Format

Podcast

Category

News · Politics

Source

RSS feed

Host

Bradley Onishi + Daniel Miller

SW

Straight White American Jesus

@straightwhiteamericanjesus

#matthewtaylor #risking #confrontchristiansupremacy

The Nile