Smooth Stone in the River

Episode 17

0:00-1:10:40

The Court has been busy, and we somehow manage to cover a number of developments with unpredictable efficiency. We talk about the Court's latest summary reversal on the "party presentation principle"; Justice Kavanaugh's vindication of his law journal student note in Pitchford v. Cain; Rutherford and Fernandez, two related cases about the intersection of compassionate release and habeas; and the DIG in Hamm v. Smith, a case about capital punishment and intellectual disability. Along the way, we also get into backlash against a certain SCOTUS advocate's TED talk and further Alabama redistricting fallout. Key Topics [00:02:25] - The infamous tweet and TED talk [00:14:56] - Alabama redistricting developments [00:19:07] - Margolin v. National Association of Immigration Judges and the Court’s renewed emphasis on the party presentation principle [00:29:02] - Pitchford v. Cain and Batson [00:35:56] - Justice Kavanaugh’s Yale Law Journal note on Batson procedure and how it connects to the case [00:40:40] - Fernandez v. United States and Rutherford v. United States: compassionate release, retroactivity, and innocence claims [01:03:34] - Hamm v.

Publisher

Divided Argument

Link

dividedargument.com/podcast/divided-argument/episode/smooth-stone-in-the-river

Published

June 1, 2026

Duration

1h 11m

Format

Podcast

Category

News · Politics

Source

RSS feed

Host

Will Baude & Dan Epps

DA

Divided Argument

@dividedargument

#smoothstone #river #government

The Nile