What is Stoicism, Really?

Episode 1

0:00-17:50

After more than a decade of studying and practising Stoicism, and nearly six years of teaching it, I don’t think the average person knows much more about it today than when I started. So in this episode I answer the question in the title as plainly as I can, after a few minutes of deliberately grumpy preamble meant to send away anyone who isn’t here to learn. Stoicism is a virtue ethics framework, which means it cares about your character and the quality of your reasoning more than rules (Deontology) or outcomes (Consequentialism). I use the example of a charity donation to show how a Utilitarian, a Kantian, and a Stoic would each explain why the act is good, and why the Stoic says it stays good even if the charity goes bankrupt the next day. From there I get into the claim underneath the whole thing: something is good when it does well what it was designed or evolved to do. A good knife cuts well, a good eye sees well, and a good human being reasons well. I explain how philosophers arrive at reason as our defining trait, why that argument is logically valid without being provably correct, and why accepting it is “rational confidence” and nothing like religious faith (gravity gets a look in here). If you won’t take that premise on board, you can still borrow Stoic tools the way Cognitive Behavioural Therapy does, but you can’t practise Stoicism. I then look at whether anything has disproven Stoicism.

Publisher

Practical Stoicism

Link

stoicism.captivate.fm/episode/what-is-stoicism-really

Published

November 11, 2026

Duration

18 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Philosophy

Source

RSS feed

Host

Tanner Campbell

PS

Practical Stoicism

@practicalstoicism

#selfimprovement

The Nile