My Christmas Cowboy Review

Episode 85

0:00-18:31

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions. Amy Acker and Luke Macfarlane team up in Hallmark's My Christmas Cowboy, and Eric came in calling this the couple he was most looking forward to all season. Was it a ringer, or did it get bucked by the bronco? Eric and Andrea both land on a 4 out of 5, but they took very different roads to get there. What You'll See: • Why the college newsroom flashback with young Meg and Billy made the present-day romance easy to buy • Andrea on why the news reporter angle saved this from being a straight cowboy movie • Luke Macfarlane as a Texan turned LA guy, complete with the wrong car and a boot full of you know what • The aw shucks moments that made Andrea hesitate, and why this beats Alison Sweeney's Romance at Hope Ranch • Eric's one real problem with the movie (spoiler: it involves a ranch) • Amy Acker, who also wrote the script, and why Eric hopes Hallmark keeps casting leads in their 50s and 60s • Three ranch-flavored Christmas picks, including Rocky Mountain Christmas with Kristoffer Polaha and Treat Williams • Christmas trivia about frontier stockings, Alabama, and a very questionable Lewis and Clark holiday dinner Chapters: 0:00 Was My Christmas Cowboy a Ringer?

Publisher

Hallmark Mysteries & More

Published

November 18, 2026

Duration

19 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Entertainment · TV & Film

Source

RSS feed

Host

Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen

HM

Hallmark Mysteries & More

@hallmarkmysteriesmore

#christmascowboyreview #tvfilm #tvreviews

The Nile