Jeremy Bamber: Five Murders. Is the Wrong Man Still in Prison? | Matthew Steeples

Episode 702

0:00-41:57

Five family members murdered. One disputed phone call. Could Jeremy Bamber be serving life for a crime he didn’t commit? --- Matthew has recently faced homelessness. If you’re able to help, you can support Matthew via PayPal (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/MatthewJSteeples). Sharing this episode and leaving a supportive comment would also mean a great deal. --- Matthew Steeples joins Andrew Gold on Heretics to examine the White House Farm murders, Jeremy Bamber’s conviction and the evidence Matthew believes demands a fresh investigation. In 1985, five members of the Bamber family were killed at their farmhouse in Essex. Jeremy Bamber was convicted the following year and has consistently maintained his innocence. But a disputed account of a 6:09am emergency call raises an unsettling question: if Bamber was outside with police, who could have been calling from inside? How did an apparent murder-suicide become a murder conviction? Why does the silencer remain so fiercely contested? And what happened to evidence that might have helped establish the truth? We explore Sheila Caffell’s story, Julie Mugford’s testimony, questions about Essex Police’s handling of the crime scene, and the investigation by The New Yorker’s Heidi Blake, discussed in the Blood Relatives podcast. Matthew explains why he changed his mind about the case—and why he believes the fight over Bamber’s conviction is far from over. Could this be a miscarriage of justice?

Publisher

Heretics | Andrew Gold

Published

October 29, 2026

Duration

42 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Documentary

Source

RSS feed

Host

Andrew Gold

H|

Heretics | Andrew Gold

@hereticsandrewgold

#jeremybamber #fivemurders #matthewsteeples

The Nile