CPTSD vs BPD: How to Think About the Difference and What to Do About It

0:00-56:14

In this episode, Dr. Malzberg and Dr. Fu tackle one of psychiatry’s hottest diagnostic debates: complex PTSD versus borderline personality disorder. They walk through the DSM-5 and ICD-11 definitional differences, the historical roots of the C-PTSD concept in Judith Herman’s work, and the real clinical distinctions clinicians can use to differentiate the two. More than a theoretical argument, the conversation zeroes in on how to communicate these diagnoses to patients, why BPD stigma drives some of the debate, and what therapies fit each presentation… from DBT and mentalization-based therapy to EMDR and trauma-focused approaches. What we cover * Why definitions come first: DSM-5 and ICD-11 define PTSD differently, and one host argues that DSM-5 PTSD, with its negative mood and cognition criterion, already covers much of what ICD-11 calls complex PTSD. * The caricatured debate (BPD as the patient's fault, complex PTSD as justified reactions) and its history in Judith Herman's Trauma and Recovery, which links borderline personality, somatization and multiple personality to trauma and to the old label hysteria. * The ICD-11 definition of complex PTSD as PTSD plus disturbances of self-organization: emotion dysregulation, negative beliefs about oneself with shame, and difficulty keeping close relationships.

Publisher

Psychofarm Podcast

Link

psychofarm.substack.com/p/cptsd-vs-bpd-how-to-think-about-the

Published

March 10, 2026

Duration

56 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Mental Health

Source

RSS feed

Host

Psychiatry, Skepticism, and Integration.

PP

Psychofarm Podcast

@psychofarmpodcast

#cptsd #difference #mentalhealth #medicine

The Nile