
9. Is AI Illegal?
Episode 9
Every AI music generator was built on other people’s songs, nearly all of them, taken without asking and without paying. The AI companies say that’s fair use, the same rule that lets a critic quote a book. Musicians say it’s theft. The answer is worth billions. Last year the U.S. Copyright Office weighed in, and the next day the head of the office was fired. So is it legal? To try and get some answers, I talk to TWO former general counsels of the Copyright Office. They're now on opposite sides of the fight. Light Box is made completely independently, with no production budget. Right now our network, Radiotopia, is holding its fall fundraiser -- and the money gets split among every show in it, including this one. A small donation goes a long way: https://bit.ly/4ziD4QT For more info go to www.LightBoxPodcast.com. Email us: Mark@LightboxPodcast.com Light Box is reported, written, edited and produced by Mark Henry Phillips at Windhill Studios. Our booking producer is Drew Thurlow. People in this Episode: Jacqueline Charlesworth, “Generative AI’s Illusory Case for Fair Use” Daniel Gervais, a memo on collective licensing for AI Sy Damle Mitch Glazier Songs in this Episode: Michael Bolton vs. the Isley Brothers, “Love Is a Wonderful Thing” George Harrison’s “My Sweet Lord” vs. the Chiffons’ “He’s So Fine” 2 Live Crew vs.
Publisher
Light Box
Link
lightboxpodcast.com/episodes/9/
Published
November 5, 2026
Duration
55 min
Format
Podcast
Category
Lifestyle · Documentary
Source
RSS feed
Host
Mark Henry Phillips & Radiotopia
Light Box
@lightbox
#aiillegal #musiccommentary
