
NFL Study of CTE: The Issues
Episode 77
In this episode of "In the Interim…", Dr. Scott Berry examines three recent health-research headlines through a statistician's lens: an Adventist Health Study-2 analysis claiming eggs reduce Alzheimer's risk, an Emory University trial on high-dose vitamin D and cognition (Zhao et al.), and a British Medical Journal study led by Dr. Daniel Danishvar (Harvard, Boston University) reporting that 25 to 97 percent of deceased NFL players showed evidence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). After flagging multiplicity and small-sample issues in the first two studies, Scott spends most of the episode on the CTE study's central flaw: because CTE can only be diagnosed after death, the published prevalence is calculated from a sample of deceased players rather than the full population of NFL players — a distinction he illustrates using a thought experiment on sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and a breakdown of the study's own age-stratified death data. He traces the resulting bias, a form of differential mortality, to a single caveat buried deep in the study's limitations section. Key Highlights Adventist Health Study-2's "27% fewer Alzheimer's diagnoses in egg-eaters" finding, and why it's likely multiplicity-driven and observational, not causal. The Emory University vitamin D study (Zhao et al.): a 13% MoCA improvement drawn from roughly eight patients, presented as a headline finding.
Publisher
In the Interim...
Link
share.transistor.fm/s/fca9d901
Published
September 7, 2026
Duration
39 min
Format
Podcast
Category
Issues · Science
Source
RSS feed
Host
Berry
In the Interim...
@intheinterim
#nflstudy #issues #mathematics #medicine
