The Dark Secrets of NY's Best Tasting Water: Rochester, NY

0:00-49:46

Rochester was voted the best-tasting municipal water in New York State. Then they found a body in the reservoir. In March 2024, a maintenance worker discovered a man's body in Rochester's Highland Park Reservoir. It had been there for 24 days while water continued flowing to tens of thousands of taps. The water tested safe, but the story of how this was possible opens up something much larger about a city drinking from two of the most protected lakes in the country while simultaneously managing 15,000 lead pipes, two reservoirs out of federal compliance for nearly 20 years, and a chemical legacy in the watershed that took state environmental archives and a stonewalled FOIL request to piece together. In this episode, environmental scientist Ally covers: 🔬 Where Rochester's water actually comes from — two glacier-carved Finger Lakes supplying 37 million gallons a day since 1876, with completely undeveloped shorelines and 6,800 acres of protected state forest. ☣️ The PCB scandal buried in the Canadice watershed. A private landowner draining transformer fluid into a tributary feeding your drinking water reservoir, and the fish test results still sitting in "draft form" two years after collection. 🚰 15,000 lead service lines still in the ground, what the city is doing about it, and how to get your water tested for free. 💀 The full story of Abdullahi Muya, the 29-year-old who drowned in Highland Park Reservoir in February 2024 and wasn't found for 24 days.

Publisher

AquaDiary: Water Mysteries, Science & News

Link

podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/aquadiarypodcast/episodes/The-Dark-Secrets-of-NYs-Best-Tasting-Water-Rochester--NY-e3j0tm7

Published

May 8, 2026

Duration

50 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Issues · Science

Source

RSS feed

Host

Ally Berry

AW

AquaDiary: Water Mysteries, Science & News

@aquadiarywatermysteriesscien

#darksecrets #tastingwater #rochester #naturalsciences

The Nile