Eddie Cahill & Carmine Giovinazzo: The Untold CSI:NY Stories & Gary Sinise's Legacy | AJ Buckley Show

Episode 46

0:00-1:12:08

What happens when three brothers from CSI: NY reunite after more than a decade and pull back the curtain on one of the biggest crime dramas in television history? This week on The AJ Buckley Show, AJ sits down with Eddie Cahill and Carmine Giovinazzo for an emotional, hilarious, and deeply personal conversation about friendship, acting, the golden era of television, and the show that changed all of their lives. Eddie opens up about his first gig on Sex and the City, the moment Sarah Jessica Parker left her cell phone number on a post-it note in his dressing room, how he shit the bed in the audition but got hired anyway after she brought producers to see him in an off-Broadway play, and the surreal experience of walking onto a Steven Spielberg set as a young unknown actor. He shares the story of landing Friends in the seventh season, meeting his manager through a holding deal that came out of nowhere, and the gamble he took when he left his agency to bet on himself. Carmine takes AJ through the wild story of how he got CSI: NY, the moment he walked into the test deal at CBS and saw Balthazar Getty sitting across from him, and the ballsy decision to ignore the rewritten sides and perform the original scene instead, telling the room it was better than the rewrites. He talks about growing up in a family of cops, knowing the character was in his blood, and the moment Anthony Zuiker laughed in the back of the room and gave him the role that would define his career.

Publisher

AJ Buckley Show

Published

September 13, 2026

Duration

1h 12m

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Philosophy

Source

RSS feed

Host

AJ Buckley

AB

AJ Buckley Show

@ajbuckleyshow

#eddiecahill #carminegiovinazzo #garysiniseslegacy

The Nile