Why Mr. Perfectly Fine Spent 13 Years in the Vault (Preview) | AP Taylor Swift After School

0:00-16:21

"How's your heart after breaking mine?" This is a preview of our paid After School episode, a continuation of our "Fearless" album deep dive. We go through every Platinum Edition bonus track and Fearless (Taylor's Version) vault track and ask the only question that matters: why didn't these make the original 13? We argue "Mr. Perfectly Fine" was too pointed for a 19-year-old still being marketed as "sweet, neat, and age-appropriate," that "Superstar" was the PR-safe version of the same heartbreak, and that the "Forever & Always" piano version is the stages of grief in song form. Subscribe for free to get episode updates or upgrade to paid to get our After School premium content: aptaylorswift.substack.com/subscribe. After School subscribers get monthly bonus episodes, exclusive content, and early access to help shape future topics! Stay up to date at aptaylorswift.com Mentioned in this episode: Luna Halo’s original “Untouchable” (2007) Valentine’s Day (2010) Hacks (HBO Max) American Fantasy by Emma Straub Ep 98: Unreliable Narrators (Mr. Perfectly Fine) Extra Credit essay on Forever Winter and the stages of grief Follow AP Taylor Swift podcast on social!

Publisher

AP Taylor Swift

Link

aptaylorswift.podbean.com/e/why-mr-perfectly-fine-spent-13-years-in-the-vault-preview-ap-taylor-swift-after-school/

Published

June 15, 2026

Duration

16 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Books

Source

RSS feed

Host

AP Taylor Swift Podcast

AT

AP Taylor Swift

@aptaylorswift

#perfectlyfinespent #years #school #musiccommentary #books

The Nile