How to Think About Lindsay Clancy

Episode 35

0:00-13:59

In this episode, I take on the Lindsay Clancy case, but not to tell you what you should think about her. Instead, I use this extraordinarily difficult case to explore how a Stoic should think when confronted with terrible acts, mental illness, questions of responsibility, and our very human desire for punishment. Apply for private coaching: https://stoicismpod.com/apply Join my free community: https://stoicismpod.com/join I begin with the facts as I understand them and an important limitation: I don't know every detail of the case or trial. Clancy killed her three children and attempted to take her own life, but she had also sought extensive psychiatric help before the killings. The defence has argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and that her condition had previously been misdiagnosed. For Stoicism, that raises an important question. The acts were hers in the causal sense, but to what extent were they hers in the moral sense? Stoic ethics places enormous importance on our capacity for rational assent. If someone's rational faculty is profoundly impaired by psychosis, then determining their responsibility requires us to consider how capable they actually were of perceiving, judging, and responding to reality rationally. That does not mean pretending the acts didn't happen, nor does compassion require us to ignore the safety of everyone else. If someone remains dangerous, restraint may be entirely appropriate.

Publisher

Practical Stoicism

Link

stoicism.captivate.fm/episode/how-to-think-about-lindsay-clancy

Published

September 22, 2026

Duration

14 min

Format

Podcast

Category

Lifestyle · Philosophy

Source

RSS feed

Host

Tanner Campbell

PS

Practical Stoicism

@practicalstoicism

#lindsayclancy #selfimprovement

The Nile